10 Best Omakase Restaurants In NYC You Must Try In 2024

Last updated:

Craving omakase in NYC? Look no further!

NYC’s not just the city that never sleeps; it’s a high-end sushi sanctuary! Here, master chefs craft sushi so exquisite, it’s a slice of Tokyo in the Big Apple.

Quick Recommendations: check out Sushi Nakazawa or 3 Michelin Starred Masa.

Ready to roll? Let’s dive into the best omakase in NYC!

This article contains affiliate links where we may get a small commission if you click on the link and purchase. No extra cost is added to you.

1. Sushi Nakazawa

(4.6) Based on 1,446 Reviews

Chef Nakazawa’s take on omakase sushi embodies the Japanese tradition and artisanship paired with exceptional hospitality.

This Michelin-starred restaurant features a sleek black-and-white space where sushi masters craft exquisite bites. 

The Omakase Menu offers around 20 varieties of Nigiri made from top-quality ingredients, especially from Japan. 

The smoked mackerel and fatty tuna served atop expertly prepared rice is a delight. 

Since Nakazawa is popular with sushi lovers, be sure to reserve a table in advance.

What to order: Omakase Menu, Bottles of Sake, Tea

Address: 23 Commerce St, New York, NY 10014, United States

Website | Instagram

2. Masa

(4.1) Based on 445 Reviews

Masa, the only three-star Michelin Japanese restaurant in New York, offers a once-in-a-lifetime sushi experience. Their Hinoki wood sushi counter, sanded daily to perfection, is a work of art. 

The minimalist decor focuses your attention on the food, crafted from peak-season ingredients to highlight their natural character. 

Masa perfectly embodies shibui, celebrating the beauty of simplicity. Each dish you taste will give you an intense burst of sushi umami heaven that leaves an impression.

What to order: Omakase

Address: The Shops at, 10 Columbus Cir Floor 4, New York, NY 10019

Website | Instagram | Facebook

3. Juku

(4.6) Based on 327 Reviews

Juku invites you to experience omakase on their top floor, guided by Chef Kazuo Yoshida. Each dish honors Japanese tradition, with diners entrusting the chef to curate the season’s best. 

The chic ambiance and Tokyo-style vibes enhance the exclusive, reservation-only omakase at 6:00 pm, 8:00 pm, and 10:00 pm. 

Chef Yoshida’s meticulous selection of fresh, high-quality ingredients ensures an impressive meal from start to finish. On your next visit, try the Chef’s Sashimi Plate on the Straylight menu, featuring 12-15 pieces of authentic sashimi.

What to order: Omakase, Chef’s Sashimi Plate

Address: 32 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013, United States

Website | Instagram | Facebook

4. Sushi Ikumi

(4.3) Based on 52 Reviews

Sushi Ikumi in SoHo offers an intimate 12-seat omakase experience using traditional Kaiseki techniques. As the sister restaurant of Hirohisa, it boasts cleanliness, excellent service, and delicious sushi. 

The Chef’s Tasting menu, lasting about 2 hours, showcases the chef’s knife mastery. Favorites include uni, futomaki, kohada, saba, and kanpachi. 

Enjoy seasonal flavors and explore their excellent beverage selection, or bring your own with corkage.

What to order: Chef’s Tasting (Omakase), Sake, Tea, Wine

Address: 135 Sullivan St, New York, NY, United States

Website | Instagram

Looking for a place to stay in New York City?

5. Sushi Amane

(4.6) Based on 141 Reviews

In the basement of Mifune, Sushi Amane offers an intimate nine-seat counter experience with top-quality ingredients and attentive service. This small Japanese restaurant sources many ingredients from Japan. 

The Omakase features five small dishes, nine nigiri sushi, tamago, a hand roll, miso soup, and dessert. 

For the nigiri sushi, you’ll get the finest seafood that tastes so fresh and delicate. Once you get a taste of this, you’ll start to appreciate the difference of each piece and how intricately they’re made.

What to order: Omakase

Address: 245 E 44th St, New York, NY 10017

Website | Instagram | Facebook

6. Shion 69 Leonard Street

(4.5) Based on 184 Reviews

Shion at 69 Leonard Street stands as a beacon of Michelin-starred excellence in the realm of sushi. Renowned sushi master Shion Uino, acclaimed for his expertise honed at Tokyo’s three-star Sushi Saito, brings Edomae-style sushi to this eight-seat stone counter setting. 

Chef Uino sources seafood directly from fishermen in his hometown of Amakusa, ensuring each nigiri is exquisitely fresh. For high-quality Japanese ingredients and impeccable taste, treat yourself to 69 Leonard Street.

What to order: Omakase

Address: 69 Leonard St, New York, NY 10013

Website | Instagram | Facebook

🗽 Explore the best of NYC with these one-day guided tours!

7. Sushi Noz

(4.7) Based on 328 Reviews

No sushi lover in New York can resist the allure of “Noz.” At Sushi Noz, you’ll step into a Sukiya-style world with nail-free cedar woodwork and a 200-year-old Hinoki wood counter.

Their Ash Room features a 6-seater counter made from rare Tamo Ash wood once used only by Japanese Nobility, offering an honorable omakase experience.

Chef Noz’s unique spins on traditional sushi are showcased in the 20-course meal, blending simplicity and intricacy. Highlights include madara with bottarga tartar and grilled nodoguro.

What to order: Edomae Style Tasting Menu, Beverage Pairing

Address: 181 E 78th St, New York, NY, United States

Website | Instagram | Facebook

8. Kanoyama

(4.3) Based on 510 Reviews

Kanoyama’s Edomae-style sushi and Chef Nobuyuki Shikanai’s skill make this omakase one of NYC’s hardest reservations to secure. 

The challenge lies in securing one of the few seats around his counter amidst loyal customers vying for those much-coveted seats.

The Michelin-starred restaurant offers a pristine space focusing on top-notch Japanese cuisine. Besides the omakase, try the hamachi carpaccio, sushi deluxe (10 pieces), and salmon don. 

Take note that the menu changes daily based on fish availability, ensuring freshness and variety!

What to order: Omakase Course, Hamachi Carpaccio, Sushi Deluxe, Salmon Don

Address: 175 2nd Ave, New York, NY, United States

Website | Instagram | Facebook

9. Sushi of Gari 46

(4.4) Based on 579 Reviews

New York is fortunate to host Sushi of Gari on 46th street that boasts a trifecta of amazing food, attentive service, and fantastic atmosphere. 

Their omakase options include sushi, sashimi, or both, showcasing the chef’s mastery with daily catches and signature toppings. The Gari’s Special features 8 unique creations, while individual nigiri like otoro, uni, and unagi shine. 

Pair your meal with Onikoroshi sake for a satisfying finish, its hint of plum and peach complements the sushi perfectly.

What to order: Omakase Sashimi and Sushi, Gari’s Special, Onikoroshi

Address: 347 W 46th St, New York, NY, United States

Website | Instagram | Facebook

10. Sushi Azabu

(4.5) Based on 357 Reviews

Azabu is a district in Tokyo that was once a commercial hub for businesses and merchants. Sushi Azabu is named after the owner’s first restaurant in the area.

Years later, Azabu is a popular omakase powerhouse in New York. Enjoy their signature Omakase, featuring otoshi, seasonal sashimi, and sushi with miso soup and dessert. 

Make sure to explore their Assorted Sashimi from the sushi bar, with favorites like o-toro and kanpachi. Their extensive beverage menu complements every dish perfectly.

What to order: Azabu Omakase, Assorted Sashimi, Organic Yuzu Matcha Tea

Address: 428 Greenwich St, New York, NY, United States

Website | Instagram | Facebook

So if you’re looking for the perfect omakase experience in New York City, then look no further than these incredible restaurants. Whether it’s a casual dinner or an upscale event, you will be able to savor the flavors of Japan like never before.

And once you’re done enjoying your omakase meal, don’t forget to check out our article on the best Brooklyn restaurants for more amazing dining experiences!

How We Create Our “Best” Lists

All Noms Magazine’s “best” lists are created using multiple factors and signals to help readers find the best restaurants, things to do, and places to stay at. Some of these factors and signs include personal experiences, correspondence with locals, and compiling experiences from review sites.

Each list is also created to be balanced (in terms of price, cuisine type, ambiance, and more) as possible. This means that the lists are not specifically created in ranking order. You should be comfortable picking from any of the spots on the list and generally have a good time. But of course, YMMV (your mileage may vary) and everyone may have different experiences/palates.