Pizza is the best food to tingle your taste buds and satisfy you with perfect combinations of flavor. And we all know that with a supreme-tasting pizza in your mouth, it just gets even more heavenly after every bite!
If you’re hanging around in Brooklyn, getting your pizza cravings fixed is easy as pizza pie! Here you can get some of the juiciest, hottest, and most breath-taking pizza you’ll ever find.
Want to know where to look? We’ve compiled a list of the best Brooklyn pizza spots in NYC! Wait no further, here are the top-rated places you can get your cravings satisfied!
1. Roberta’s
Roberta’s is known for their wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza that always hits the spot! This hipster aesthetic pizza house doesn’t only make quality pizzas, but you can assure that their assortments of bread, teas, cheese, pizzas, and prosciutto are top-notch.
One of their most sought-after flavors is their Bee Sting Pizza. This crowd-pleaser pizza is all Soppressata goodness, overloaded cheese, slathered with a honey finish. It equalizes the savory notes with the honey’s sweetness plus a nice kick from the chili.
If you’re into thin crust pizzas, you’ll love it even more because its crust is made extra thinner making it easier to eat–highlighting the flavored goodies of the pizza.
To balance out the flavors, what goes best with the Bee Sting Pizza is their new pie called Clam Pie. Consisting of steamed clams and mozzarella cheese, it makes the tummy stuffed with the overpowering flavor of clam. With the loaded seafood flavors in it, it’s a unique pizza that’s worth all the hype.
What to order: Bee Sting Pizza, Clam Pie, Little Neck Pasta.
Address: 6 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
2. L&B Spumoni Gardens
If you’re looking for some old-school Sicilian square pizza, L&B Spumoni Gardens is the pizzeria that will hit that classic pizza spot for you! Opened in 1939, this pizzeria is known to serve some of the most classic flavors of pizza with of course, their rocking ice cream.
Enjoying their food is even better with the ambiance that surrounds the place. Chill vibes is the first impression you’ll get as you enter inside. Available with both indoor and outdoor seating, it’s all comfortability in everywhere you sit.
This NYC icon is nothing like your typical New York-Style pizza as it’s molded into a square shape, and has an extra thicker crust, with some baked-in goat cheese & sweet sauce. It takes the win for being one of the most distinct and favorite pizzas of the town!
If you’re looking for something classic and super duper tasty, their simple Cheese Pizza is always the go-to. Always fresh out of the oven and is loaded with cheese all over. The chewy, crunchy flavors all at once are simply phenomenal.
For dessert, try out their Spumoni Ices. We recommend you get the Vanilla Chip one. It’s divine in every way, shape, and form! The creaminess is out of this world and the sweetness doesn’t compare to any other dessert! A total no-miss, that’s for sure.
What to order: Sicilian Pizza, Cheese Pizza, and Vanilla Chip Spumoni Ice.
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
3. Di Fara Pizza
A simple pizzeria that always has top-grade flavorings when it comes to their selection, that’s what you get in Di Fara Pizza. This no-frills storefront takes pride in serving handcrafted pizza by the master himself.
The atmosphere is homey and cozy. It’s your typical NYC pizzeria spot but the taste of each and every pizza isn’t so typical as the flavors are off the charts!
What makes this place iconic is the intensely flavored basil taste in their Regular Pie. If you happen to drop by, all you need to try out is their regular pie and you’re on your way to pure satisfaction. It’s infused with fresh chunks and of course, a christening of fresh basil and drizzled olive oil. All those ingredients together create a spectacular boldness to every bite you take.
Don’t skip their Chaos Pie if you’re a fresh garlic and sausage type of pizza lover. The pizza slice is extra crunchy all the way except for the tip which boasts a soft and dewy texture. The sausages and meatballs are especially flavorful and the combination of cherry tomatoes just makes it the bomb!
What to order: Regular Pie, Square Pie, and Chaos Pie
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
4. Lucali
Looking for an upscale brick-oven pizzeria to give you some of the best pizza flavors in Brooklyn? Look no further because Lucali is the upscale pizzeria that has just what you’re looking for.
The traditional brick-oven pizzas are always best here in Lucali as it gives you a glimpse of Italy with how its made, presented, and the magnificent taste. Dining in is also as amazing as their pizza, the simple laidback resto has a rustic-looking interior with basic wooden chairs and tables. From their chill atmosphere down to their oh-so-good pizza, you’re surely going to make this your go-to pizzeria!
You won’t regret getting their Plain Pizza. Unlike its name, it’s not your regular pizza because the bursting goodness of every ingredient stands out graciously! It’s close to the taste of pizzas in Italy–large, filling, and insanely flavorful.
You can even choose your own toppings but we recommend you get the artichoke and jalapenos for the pizza toppings. It complements the red sauce and the overall overpowering taste of their pizza.
Their Pepperoni Pizza is also the bomb. Loaded with fresh hot peppers and fresh garlic, plus the super thin crust that just has that crisp crackle when you bite makes it out-of-this-world spectacular. They’re also generous when it comes to pepperoni. With the pepperoni flavor popping out the most, everything about this pizza is pure magnificence!
What to order: Plain Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza
Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
5. L’Industrie Pizzeria
What better way to spend a day in Williamsburg than dining on a mouthwatering slice of pizza? With a shelf that’s lined with rows of imported Italian pizza ingredients and plenty of booths set up in a covered street outside, L’Industrie Pizza provides you with the ultimate New York Pizza experience.
From the bustling kitchen, the friendly staff, and the music ranging from old-school hip-hop to classic rock, this place is as lively as it gets.
There’s a reason why L’Industrie’s New Yorker pizza got its name, and if the whooping pepperonis and sausages are not enough to convince you, what else can? For some reason, the combination of these two simple ingredients topped with fresh basil creates the best pizza in the whole of NYC.
From your first bite to your last, the Margherita pizza hits almost like vodka in a good way. The sauce just hits differently, and the edge of the pepperoni cups curls up so well. The sweet crust complements Margherita’s slightly alcoholic taste.
What to order: New Yorker, Margherita
Address: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Website | Instagram | Facebook
6. Krispy Pizza
Krispy Pizza is an all-time favorite family-owned neighborhood pizzeria that offers some old-school Brooklyn-style pizzas. With about 15 specialty pizzas, Krispy Pizza makes sure that you leave their place with a palate fulfilled with intensely bursting Italian flavors.
Inside their classic resto is an interior that highlights roman-inspired ornaments like decorative pillars and hung plate-painted works. Living up to their name of being an all-time fave pizzeria, Krispy Pizza gives you a taste of heaven in every slice of their thin-crust Sicilian pizza!
One of their beautifully crafted pizza is called the Vodka Pizza. It’s phenomenal through and through. The taste of vodka kicks in just one bite and just like its name, the crust has that crispy crunch to it.
The flavors of vodka mixed with the sesame seed pizza dough are on point. Add a little more vodka sauce, get some of their regular mozzarellas, and we promise you it boosts the taste ten times better!
If you want to try out multiple pizza flavors all at once, get their Trio Pizza which is a split pizza between three flavors; pesto, vodka, and marinara. Any flavor that you’re craving, this pizza can definitely live up to whatever you’re looking for. The marinara flavor really slaps nicely to the tastebuds as the strong notes of garlic, crushed red pepper flakes, and aromatic herbs of basil and oregano.
Their Margharita Pizza is something different but is a masterpiece in every way. It’s a must-have especially if you’re a sweet and tangy pizza enthusiast. Balancing the sweetness and tanginess with some fresh mozzarella cheese plus the hard-kneaded pizza base, eating this Italian delight gets addicting each and every time you take a bite.
What to order: Vodka Pizza, Trio Pizza, and Margherita Pizza.
Address: 7112 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
7. Leo
Leo is the locals’ go-to laidback pizza place serving only the most delicious Sourdough Pizza, paired with seasonal Vegetables and some classic fine wine. In this easy-going pizza hub, you get both indoor and outdoor dining that’s sure to give you a comfortable and fun time. It’s everything you need for your casual hangout sesh with friends.
The crowd favorites are the Clam Pie and the NYC Slice Pie. The Clam Pie is big for the clam lovers out there that love a fresh set of flavorful clams on their pizza topped with oozing mozzarella cheese. It’s scrumptious to the taste and is incredible in terms of texture. That crispy crackling crust never misses, it’s a true winner indeed!
For the NYC Slice Pie, what makes this a total banger is the little unique kick it gives when you first take a bite. Truly one of the best ones in the city because of its simple layered toppings of cheese, tomato sauce, and some good-tasting meat!
Next up on their list of drooling-good pizzas is their Potato Pie. One slice and you won’t get enough of its carby, creamy, starchy potatoes that melt in your mouth graciously. Married with the tangy sourdough crust along with that gush of cheesy relish, this pizza is definitely something else!
What to order: Clam Pie, NYC Slice Pie, and Potato Pie
Address: 123 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
8. Lombardo’s of Bay Ridge
Tucked in small spot in Brooklyn is where you can find the finest artisan pizzas! In Lombardo’s Bay of Ridge, you can assure that brag-worthy and generously topped brick-oven pies is what you’ll have in your stomach plus an ocean of happy tastebuds swarming in your tongue.
This rustic place boasts a comfy atmosphere with its brick walls and vintage-inspired ornaments. Giving off a cozy atmosphere in every corner, the focus is on all their signature delicious pizzas!
Get a hold of their Funghi Pizza that features the yummiest portobello shrooms, briny prosciutto, red onions, and truffle-infused olive oil. This pizza tastes exceptional and the flavors melt in your tongue altogether making each munch even more enjoyable than the previous one.
Their Margherita Pie is also a drooling option that you should try. It’s thin crust, perfectly crisp, and infused with just the right amount of char to season it well. And with the hint of fresh tomatoes and mozzarella, prepare yourself to be drawn in by this special pizza every single time!
Of course, pizza as a dessert beats any dessert known to mankind. With that, try out their sweet Nutella Pie. Garnished with Strawberries, drizzled caramel, and oh-so-creamy whipped cream, this dessert pizza is enough to make you come back again for another round!
What to order: Funghi Pizza, Margherita Pie, and Nutella Pie.
Address: 279 71st St, Brooklyn, NY,
9. J & V Pizzeria
A place for warm and tasty traditional pizzas is what J&V Pizzeria is best known for. Up and running since the 1950s, this pizzeria is home for multitudes of memories backed with timeless pies that are worth coming back to.
With its classic clean interior, some things never change in this small pizza hub but be assured that their pizzas just get better and better!
Their Veggie Slice never ceases to impress! Covered with some amazingly fresh veggies and the oozing delicious taste of the sauce, one slice isn’t even enough to make you get over how deliciously flavorful this veggie pizza is.
You should also try out their Sicilian Slice if you want a classic yet *chef’s kiss* pizza. Served large, crunchy, all smeared with just the perfect cheese and sauce ratio, you’ll never regret ordering this classic goodie!
For something a little complex and striking to the taste palate, their Buffalo Slice is a game-changer! The distinct tangy and spicy taste of buffalo chicken provides a richer flavor than all of its other pizza flavors.
What to order: Veggie Slice, Sicilian Slice, and Buffalo Slice.
Address: 6322 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
10. Mo’s General
A local favorite crafted by a local resident! Mo’s General is your neighborhood pizzeria that slaps excellence after excellence in their handcrafted well-packed pizzas.
Whether you’re looking for a fresh outdoor setting or a cozy indoor setup, you won’t be disappointed because they have everything you need to make your experience 5/5. Settle down and let the wonders of their pizza bring you to heavenly goodness!
If you’re a pizza junky, their pepperoni and white pizza are their bestsellers and best believe that they are for a reason. Prep yourself because these two pies will never let you down. The pepperoni slice is down to beat your expectations with that powerful garlicky red sauce and loaded pieces of pepperoni. A red sauce that’s both tangy with a touch of sweetness to it plus the addition of basil, call it over-the-top amazing!
The white pizza is the perfect homemade grandma-style pizza. The crunchy cheese crust and amazing depth of flavor definitely make it heaven in a form of a pizza!
What to order: Pepperoni Pizza and White Pizza
Address: 620 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY
11. Giuseppina’s Brick Oven Pizza
Giuseppina’s Brick Oven Pizza is a quaint pizzeria offering crazy delicious pizza that’s just perfect for every hungry pizza lover down the block! A menu filled with mouthwatering pizza flavors and an ambiance that ensures an easy-going environment will entice you to eat more and more while you have overflowing conversations with your loved ones.
Try out their Base Pizza Pie and get it with red bell peppers, onion, mushrooms, and baby arugula. The rich flavor of the sauce and the super duper freshness of the basil truly make it impeccable!
Their Everything Pie is also one you shouldn’t miss. It’s full of toppings and has the best combination of everything tasty and fresh such as buffalo, low-moisture mozzarella cheese, beef, tomato sauce and more. With this pizza, you can assure that you get the most out of your money’s worth. Prepare for that tummy-filled goodness that’s soon to come back empty and hungry for more!
Their Nutella Calzone is a must for dessert. Filled with honey ricotta and drizzled with some overloaded sweet Nutella and the light-dusted powdered sugar, it tastes just like a dream. After the savory tastes of pizza, this one is sure to cap off your meal in ways you’ll love!
What to order: Base Pizza Pie, Everything Pie, and Nutella Calzone
Address: 691 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY,
12. Paulie Gee’s
Not like any other pizza spot, Paulie Gee’s is a gourmet pizzeria specializing in wood-fired pies that are garnished with some of the most unique locally sourced ingredients! A lot of varieties and a whole of memorable moments await you in this Brooklyn-famous pizzeria.
Boasting a cool old-school vibe, their dark wood and low-lighting interior definitely does the trick in keeping the customers in and happy. It’s just a snug feeling when you walk in and an even snugger feeling walking out with a stomach filled with crazy delicious pizza flavors!
If you’re a vegan, this place is going to be listed under your faves. They have excellent vegan options such as their Vegan Pizza and their The Apple Pie With Vegan Vanilla Ice Cream.
For the Vegan Pizza, you won’t even notice that it’s vegan. That’s how good it is. The crust is rightly tan on the bottom, crispy but not burned. The tomato sauce is light and fresh. The tanginess just balanced and complements the overall taste of the toppings.
Their Ricky Ricotta Pizza had dollops of ricotta, arugula, plus some fennel sausage. The combo of these three are heavenly giving you fresh, slightly nutty, with combos of both sweet and savory notes. With added cashew cheese on this pizza, there’s nothing more you can ask for. It’s truly a blessing for the palate!
What to order: Vegan Pizza, Apple Pie with Vegan Vanilla Ice Cream, and Ricky Ricotta Pizza.
Address: 60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Website | Instagram | Facebook
That ends our list of the best pizza places in Brooklyn. Want something else? We’ve still got the perfect list for you. Check out the 27 best restaurants in Brooklyn and get ready to make your way to some jaw-dropping food!
Looking for a place to stay in New York?
This article includes affiliate links where we may get a small commission if you use our link. No extra cost is added to you.