New York is a safe haven for all the kosher food lovers in the city.
Literally, this town has everything your palate is craving, from Texas-style barbecue to sushi to pizza to more traditional items, like matzoh ball soup, blintzes, and pastrami sandwiches, which even appeal to non-Jewish diners!
Here are some of the best Kosher restaurants in NYC that you should visit once! You can’t go wrong with those hidden gems!
1. Abaita
Struggling to find the best kosher pizza in New York? Abaita has got your back! This spot has been at the top of the list since it first opened back in 2018, and is widely loved by the locals for its modern and intimate design.
Start off with the Margherita pizza, probably the best thing on the menu. You can try the Piccante Pizza for a tastebud kick! The contrast between the sweetness of the honey and the spiciness of the spicy Salami is sure to excite your palate.
If you’re in the mood for seafood, take the Yellowfin Tuna Tartare, which has a rich, buttery flavor that melts in your mouth. Or the Crispy Salmon served with lime-dill dipping sauce is no less mouth-watering!
What to order: Yellowfin Tuna Tartare, Piccante Pizza, Lasagna, Crispy Salmon, Margherita Pizza
Address: 145 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017
Website | Instagram | Facebook
2. Reserve Cut
Located inside Setai Wall Street, Reserve Cut is a high-end steakhouse that offers from surprisingly delicious steaks and burgers to well-prepared fish in a spacious yet cozy setting. We also suggest you order a couple of sushi rolls when visiting Reserve Cut, trust us, you will be amazed!
For steaks, you must order the Prime Cut, a 14-ounce dry-aged ribeye that is beyond tender and perfectly seasoned, which can possibly be the best steak you’ve ever had recently! Then grab the Golden Age Burger with a blend of prime chuck & short rib, caramelized onions, white truffle butter, and served with fried pickles!
For the most signature rolls at Reserve Cut, go for The Broad Street Roll filled with spicy tuna, tempura crunch, seared tuna, mayo, and masago. In case you still have room for some more, end it right with the crispy, smoky yet tatsy Grilled Chilean Sea Bass. Its taste is amazingly remarkable!
What to order: Grilled Chilean Sea Bass, The Broad Street Roll, The Prime Cut, Golden Age Burger
Address: 40 Broad St 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10004
Website | Instagram | Facebook
3. Barnea Bistro
Barnea Bistro is a quiet, casual bistro in Midtown, where you can find a bit of everything in their comforting, wide menu. On a day when you don’t know what’s for lunch or dinner, pay a visit to Barnea Bistro, they have just the right thing for you!
Settle down with some Beef Carpaccio or Beef Tartare, which is not usually found on most kosher menus. While the carpaccio is drizzled with truffle oil to enhance that rich umami taste, the tartare is seasoned with house sauce and packed with flavors!
Keep going on with the Polenta Fries made with truffle honey, and the Lyonnaise Salad as a side dish, which features a soft poached egg, amb bacon, walnuts, mustard vinaigrette, farro, and pickled onion. Don’t miss their Fish Tacos too! They are a hidden gem!
What to order: Lamb Riblets, Beef Tartare, Polenta Fries, Fish Tacos, Lyonnaise Salad
Address: 211 E 46th St, New York, NY 10017
Website | Instagram | Facebook
4. Izzy’s Brooklyn Smokehouse
There aren’t that many kosher smokehouses in the town, so Izzy’s Brooklyn Smokehouse has long been the locals’ favorite joint for smoked brisket, pulled beef, and turkey for a reason. Once enter Izzy, we bet you’ll be seduced by not the decadent aroma coming out from the kitchen but the lovely, laid-back ambiance as well!
Honestly, everything on the menu is worth trying. But you might want to start with their sandwiches, such as the Loaded Chili Sausage served with a house-made sauce and coleslaw, or the Smoked Fried Chicken prepared on toasted brioche with horseradish mayo and pickles.
Barbecue Taco is another highlight, which is filled with 18-hour smoked brisket in corn tortillas, topped with fresh pico de gallo, horseradish mayo, and drizzled with barbecue sauce. Your tummy will be so happy for this juicy, tender, flavorsome badass!
What to order: Pulled Beef Fries, Smoked Brisket Tacos, Thai Sticky Ribs, Barbecue Tacos
Address: 397 Troy Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213
Website | Instagram | Facebook
5. Rothschild TLV
Rothschild TLV is where you’ll be immersing yourself in such a luxurious and modern setting while enjoying fine Israeli food. Come by to see how your beloved traditional dishes turned into modern classics under the hand of Chef Tal Abaov.
The menu includes standouts like Holy Ravioly, saffron & black garlic ravioli filled with beef cheek, chestnuts, caramelized onions, and served with corn cream; Bluefin Tuna Crust Salad with aromatically spiced tuna crust, bean noodles, avocado slice, and root vegetables with Asian vinaigrette. Feels like heaven in every bite!
Don’t miss their Lamb Burgers, which are served on a bed of grilled vegetables and topped with a zesty yogurt-based sauce. A delicious twist on standard burger fare! Or the Slow-cooked Beef Cheek that is a wonderfully melt-in-your-mouth, rich, and tender delicacy.
What to order: Bluefin Tuna Crust Salad, Holy Ravioly, Spicy Salmon, Lamb Burger
Address: 1129 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10075
Website | Instagram | Facebook
6. Nish Nush
Serving up casual Middle Eastern fare, Nish Nush is a reliable spot to find falafel-based sandwiches and platters that are far more filling than your average nosh. Give it a try and you’d wish to know this place sooner!
Must-try includes Crispt Chickpea Balls that come in 3 tempting flavors for you to choose from: an herb-flecked green, a spicy roasted red pepper, and a hearty spinach-and-mushroom variety. Try them all or regret it later! You can choose some veggies or pita to eat with them too.
Then, grab the spicy Chili Falafel Burger stuffed with lettuce, avocado, tomato, jalapeno, mayo & Mediterranean barbecue sauce, and roasted pepper. If you can’t handle the heat, then choose the Popeye Delight Sandwich or Deluxe Sandwich instead!
What to order: Crisp Chickpea Balls, Chili Falafel Burger, Popeye Delight Sandwich, Garlic & Tomato Hummus Platter, Avocado Salad
Address:
– 41 John St, New York, NY 10038
– 88 Reade St, New York, NY 10013
Website | Instagram | Facebook
7. Alenbi
Alenbi is a modern Israeli restaurant serving both Ashkenazic and Sephardic fare in Crown Heights. This lovely place is placed with large windows and spacious tables, which makes it perfect for any big group or family gathering.
There are plenty of choices to choose from, and you can choose to start with Kruvit first, a wood-oven charred cauliflower dish. Then comes the Falafel Deconstructed with Alenbi’s famous falafel made fresh with fava bean, sumac, onion, chickpea crumble, chili pepper, cilantro, and pita bread. People keep coming back for this one, so we bet you’d love it too!
For a more hearty one, go for their Souvlaki consisting of small cubes of skewered and grilled, chicken, shaved veal, and lamb, along with grilled onion and cabbage. Or Lamb Arayes with pita stuffed with seasoned ground lamb served with charred veggies. Totally a chef kiss!
What to order: Falafel Deconstructed, Souvlaki, Tartare Shuk, Lamb Arayes, Kruvit
Address: 887 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Website | Instagram | Facebook
8. Turquoise Kosher Fish Restaurant
Searching for a unique Mediterranean seafood experience? Head to Fresh Meadows in eastern Queens to Turquoise Kosher Fish Restaurant! The food here is always fresh and never too heavily dressed with any unnecessary sauces, including raw, grilled, broiled, or deep fried depending on the texture of the flesh.
Highlights of the menu are Tuna Carpaccio with thinly sliced tuna served on a bed of radishes, and cucumber, and dressed with lemon zest. Fresh yet full of umami taste and amazingly soft, bouncing texture. Or you can choose the Sesame Seared Tuna which is no less delicious with crusted pan-seared tuna loin sliced and served with soy vinaigrette.
Don’t forget to have the Homemade Biscuit Cake for dessert, this is absolutely worth trying with layers of tea biscuits, vanilla, and chocolate pudding, then topped with chopped walnuts and chocolate. Sweet, rich, and creamy as ever!
What to order: Israeli Salad, Tuna Carpaccio, Chilean Sea Bass, Sesame Seared Tuna, Homemade Biscuit Cake
Address: 189-23 Union Tpke, Fresh Meadows, NY 11366
9. Kosher In Midtown
Located in the middle of Midtown New York, Kosher in Midtown is a fast-paced Kosher restaurant with a variety of cuisines, ranging from Chinese cuisine, Chicken wings, and Sushi, to Hawaiian bowls of food, and a selection of vegetarian dishes for you to choose from.
If you’re in the mood for some dumplings, pass by Eden Wok and get their famous Steamed Dumplings dipped in the sour, spicy house sauce. They also have sashimi and noodles as well! But remember to save room for some sushi rolls shaped as a filling donut and topped with choices of vegetables and fish at Sushi Donut Shop as well!
Koshe Poke is where you’ll be trying some signature Hawaiian customizable Poke bowls and seaweed burritos with a selection of proteins and vegetables. Finally, stop at Buffalo2go to try their Kosher wings in 12 different flavors such as honey barbeque, smoked chipotle, and sesame sriracha. Finger-licking good!
What to order: Steamed Dumplings in Spicy Sauce, 12-flavor Chicken Wings, Sushi Donut Box, Pitopia Falafel
Address: 43 E 34th St, New York, NY 10016
Website | Instagram | Facebook
10. Noi Due Cafe
Noi Due Cafe has long been a famous joint for serving delectable Italian cuisine with a Mediterranean twist. People love coming here for their crisp, brick-oven pizza. So come by, munching on any slice of pizza while enjoying the casual, upbeat ambiance.
Start with the smoky, spicy Eggplant Carpaccio with creamy vegan cashew spread. Then go on with the Truffle Pizza with savory mushrooms and gooey cheese finished off with a truffle oil that infuses the entire pie! This earthy, incredibly flavorful pizza is totally a masterpiece!
Remember to get the Taboon Roasted Whole Branzino with whole fish stuffed with lemon and rosemary. And don’t hesitate to ask them for their Kosher wine of the day to pair with your meal. You’ll love it!
What to order: Eggplant Carpaccio, Slow Roasted Red Beets, Truffle Pizza, Taboon Roasted Whole Branzino, Sole Marsala
Address: 491 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024
Website | Instagram | Facebook
11. Eighteen
Eighteen is the hidden gem of the Kosher world, featuring stunning sushi and grilled meats, alongside special holiday menus and a separate catering menu. Once stepped inside, you’ll be seduced by its contemporary wood settings, candle-lit tables, a big bar, and cozy couches. A classy yet feel-like-home ambiance!
Highlights of the menu include the Eighteen Signature Pizza, which we all love, comes up with tuna, crispy dough with signature sauce, and is drizzled with earthy truffle oil. And the Bello Beef Burger which is topped with grilled marinated portobello mushrooms and sauteed onion. Juicy, melt-in-mouth texture, and is packed with flavors!
You can also check on their rolls, especially the Golden Roll with salmon, crunchy cucumber, and buttery avocado. In case you go in a group, choose the Eighteen King’s Plater with a huge portion of rib steak, lamb chop, chicken breast, and beef kebab.
What to order: Eighteen Signature Pizza, Bello Beef Burger, Golden Roll, Eighteen King’s Platter
Address: 240 E 81st St, New York, NY 10028
Website | Instagram | Facebook
12. Bodhi Kosher Vegetarian Restaurant
In the mood for some Chinese food? Then Bodhi is definitely the place you need to visit! Serving Cantonese-style food with a wide range of vegetarian options, Bodhi can immediately comfort you not only with its food but with its homey and casual atmosphere as well!
The Sticky Rice Sesame Balls are considered the best-sellers of Bodhi, which have a crispy exterior with a chewy interior, and a toasty, nutty, sweet taste. They also have a savory version of sesame balls too, so don’t hesitate to try them both!
Now it’s time for some dumplings! Get the Steamed Soup Dumplings with a rich, savory soup coming out from the dumplings, and Fried Taro Dumplings stuffed with meat filling and have a honeycomb-like crispy exterior. Stunning!
What to order: Sticky Rice Sesame Balls, Fried Taro Dumplings, BBQ Veg Meat Fried Rice, Steamed Vegetable Meat Bun, Steamed Soup Dumplings
Address: 77 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013
Website | Instagram | Facebook
We hope you’ve found yourself that ideal place for your next Kosher meal. Keep your food journey going with these best Brooklyn restaurants here!
Looking for a place to stay in NYC?
This article includes affiliate links where we may get a small commission if you use our link. No extra cost is added to you.